Friday, July 8, 2011

On compensation in the Red Zone

Expectations are WAY too high. Some people are bitching about the government's offer to pay them Rateable value for their house and section in the red zone.
"But my house was worth way more than that". Well your decision not to appeal the RV in order to try and keep your rates low was, in retrospect, a bad idea. But it was your choice.  Actually, that's pretty harsh - most people wouldn't even think to bother either way.  And there is a real problem that RV is often miles away from market value.  But gov't has said that it may address that by letting people appeal the valuation.  No firm details on that yet.  But if we do 5,000 and an average of an extra $25,000, then thats $125 million - which is a lot new hips or other medical procedures.  Lets not forget that compensation is not free!

"It's not fair - I had my house insured for replacement value". Yep; life's a bitch; but don't blame the insurance companies for not having sold you a policy for something none of us thought of. And you are no worse off than if you'd sold your house the day before the earthquake.  Which is in stark contrast to farmers who lost half a farm to cyclone Bola or whatever torrential rainstorm came down last year.

"I won't be able to replace my house for that money". Just because you had a house in the cheap part of town and there is no other cheap part to move to is no reason why anyone should actually make you financially better off as a result of an earthquake.  That said, this one IS pretty tricky.  I have a brilliant idea for solving it - which is that people co-operatively buy a chunk of land and then subdivide, saving themselves the risk margin which developers want (and you can see why, when you note how many of them have gone broke).  I've done the numbers (and for a month had an option to purchase a block at Halswell in the zone which the city wants to develop), and you can generate sections for around $120,000.  The thing is that developers want about a 50 % margin for risk (that is to say 30 - 40 % of the section sale price).  Whereas if you WANT a section, there is no risk for you, and you can save the risk premium.

"But I'm not insured".  Oh; you decided not to insure did you? Wanted to take your chances. Well, this was your chance! Not pretty maybe, but thats the way the dice fell this year.  .  I think of the insurance company as being the organisers of a community effort, whereby we all pay in and we all get compensated if the unthinkable happens.  When you refuse to insure, you are actually refusing to do your bit to help those who had the unthinkable happen to them this year.  If you really hate what you see as rip-off insurers making a fortune, buy some insurance company shares at the same time.  (I do feel sorry for those with bare land which is not actually insurable with EQC - maybe that will change)

I never thought about the possiblity of an earthquake leaving my house OK but on written-off land - and maybe as a community we'll sort out the insurance to cover for this next time. But as a community we've been whacked. No one can expect to be made better off as a result, and its a bugger that some of us are going to be quite a bit worse off. But if it had happened to me I like to think that while I'd be really pissed at life; I'd not be pissed at what seems a pretty good offer to me by government acting on behalf of the community.  I repeat, this is not FREE.  We all pay sooner or later for this handout.

I really am sorry for people living smashed houses and in some cases appalling physical conditions, and if I can help them by giving them a hand to do stuff I will - but not by making them financially better off than they were before the quake.

I hate the inefficiency with which we are addressing some of this stuff - but that seems to be the way large organisations work - with quite a bit of it being to stop the darker side of human nature expressing itself through rip-offs.  I've also been amazed at how willing the crowd is to  follow the loud leader in the fluoro jacket, who invariably insists on being safety first - and in fact safety only!; and how much opprobrium you attract by being "difficult" and refusing to be a follower. The people who believe in self determination (i.e. leaving people to make their own choice) are, almost by definition, not the leaders in the fluoro jackets.

That opprobrium is all part of the same mindset which can't help blaming a parent whose child is abducted for letting their child walk alone to school, accepting the one in a million, or is it 10 million, chance that there will be a nutter on the street today.  Very few people see it as the rational process of giving a child responsibility, fresh air and independence, with the risk that this entails.

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

Destroying Value

10 march 2011
If Gerry Brownlie (Minister for Earthquake Recovery) had his way, all the ChCh heritage buildings, apart from the half a dozen on his list, would have a bulldozer through them tomorrow, in fact yesterday - "people's lives are more important than buildings.  If all these buildings had been knocked down after the first earthquake, then many people would be alive today".  Well the new is Gerry that the major losses of life were in the non-heritage buildings (CTV circa 1976 and Pyne Gould Corp circa 1962).  And the other news is that this appears to be a very uncommon earthquake with massive accelerations that were way beyond earthquake codes.  The buildings would quite possibly have fallen regardless of any weakening that might have occurred in the first earthquake.

As a community we need the guts to say, "Life is risky, and we should continue to live with some risks, rather than try to demolish them all away".   We can't do it anyway, and trying to do it could cause us huge costs in terms of financial losses, or the destruction of our environment. 

Lives are not beyond price! We make life - money trade-offs every day ("No, we can't afford to give you that operation"), and after two weeks to calm down a bit, people need to be given some freedom to make their own choices.  If some bloke wants to be given a month to construct some clever, or even very risky, way of getting out his 20 heritage motor cars before his building is demolished, let him.   If some woman wants to get into her creaking house with a hard hat on to try and find the treasured photos and family jewellery and bible before the place is crunched, let her.  Yes someone MAY die or be injured, but a lot of other people WILL save things which are either very valuable to them and us as a community


If I had my way, Gerry would go back to teaching woodwork and leave decisions to be made by those directly affected, and I'd like everyone to stand back and let a lot of individuals make their own calls.  What has actually fallen over in the after shocks?

If you are ever in any disaster such as this, recognise that you have 12 - 24 hours to sort things out your way, taking whatever risks you think are appropriate, before someone takes control and insists they be sorted out the official way - which will be low risk, prevent you taking what you think are perfectly reasonable risks, and probably destroy a hell of a lot of value.